Kombo : : : PS3 | 360 | Wii | Cube | Xbox | PSP | DS | Forums | Podcasts

AROUND KOMBO:
REVIEW
God of War Collection
The PS2 games upgrade to PS3 visuals
REVIEW
Resident Evil: Darkside Chronicles
Play the lost chapters of the RE timeline.
REVIEW
REVIEW: LittleBigPlanet PSP
It's fun, but lonely without multiplayer.
Superman Returns: The Videogame
Console
Nintendo DS
Publisher
Electronic Arts
Genre
Action
Developer
EA Tiburon
Release Date
11/20/06
3
ESRB Rating
Everyone
StumbleUpon Toolbar  
Superman Returns
Krrrrryptonite! For your DS, that is.
December 28, 2006 | 12:45 PM PST

by: Weston Bass

In what is sure to come as a surprise to gamers everywhere, the latest in a long line of movie to game adaptations is, in fact, terrible. While I am in no way a connoisseur of the Man of Steel or his intricate canon, I can tell you that if you consider yourself a fan of Kal-El, stay far, far away from this portable travesty. If you’re still reading this in the misguided hope that there is at least some small redeeming sliver of quality in this steaming pile of digital feces, allow me to crush your dreams.

You start your game by choosing a difficulty level and from one of nine versions of Superman. Not knowing much of these different adaptations I can’t say the option gave me the tingling feelings they might a more dedicated fan. The game opens with you piloting your Krytpon spaceship back to earth. The controls lack the option for traditional inverted flight controls, but after a few moments of frustration I was able to begin my campaign to save Metropolis from the nefarious schemes of Lex Luthor and other super villains.

The city is broken down into a board game style grid, where Superman and his Nemeses battle for real estate. Each turn starts with stamina points which you spend in various amounts traversing across the grid. Once you land on an event or villain space the game loads one of an array of missions or boss battles. While this is where the fun should start, it brings nothing but pain, with the occasional gnashing of teeth.

Missions are the most basic of mini-games involving time limited flights through obstacle courses or countless romps through a barren Metropolis in simple and repetitive fetch quests. These range from discovering androids posing as law abiding citizens to sequences pulled from the film. There are a handful of variations, but you’ll have experienced them all within the first hour of playing.

Boss battles somehow succeed in turning something as awesome as a one and one duel between Superman and his universe’s many villains into a thoughtless and mind numbing rhythm game. You read that right. Instead of actually fighting bosses you watch Superman trade blows as your performance in the fight is matched by your ability to press buttons in time. It’s like DDR for your thumbs without the music or the fun.

After each round the health of Metropolis is calculated based on the number of spaces Superman and the villains hold and how successful you were at completing the mission or boss battle. If Metropolis loses too much health it’s game over. The different difficulty settings do nothing more than decrease the time limit in which you must get to work at the Daily Planet or other missions and the rate at which you must press buttons during boss battles.

To top this all off, there are constant loading screens between missions. Loading screens on a DS game are inexcusable to begin with, but these set a new level in both frequency and duration. You might think someone secretly swapped your DS for a PSP.

The graphics are a mix of 3D and cel-shading, which works well given the material. However Metropolis seems like a ghost town with its only inhabitants related specifically to the mission at hand. Occasional popup and fog abound. It’s not the ugliest DS game, but it’s not that pretty either.

Kryptonite... For Your DS
This game is another example of sloppy game design and hurried development in an attempt to cash in on a big time franchise. There is really nothing redeeming about this game and you'd be best served to ignore it completely.

-- Weston Bass
Visuals
The comic book inspired art works well in the game, but the 3D graphics leave Metropolis feeling desolate.
5.5
Sound
The familiar themes from the film are present and sound effects are adequate.
5.0
Control
Flying offers no inverted control and navigating the narrow corridors of the city is difficult with the d-pad.
4.0
Gameplay
Disappointing game design all around. From the lame rhythm based boss fights to the button combination mission objectives, nothing about this game is actually fun.
3.0
Lasting Appeal
There is a multiplayer mode that revolves around the same board game mechanic as the single player game, but that would require making your friends all buy a copy of this waste of silicon.
3.0
Verdict
Really, if you've read this far you know that the term shovelware was made for games like this. Save your money and time. Fans of Superman will have more fun rewatching the movie or sticking to the comics.
3.0
[not an average]
Review Scores Guide

Got something that we should post on the site? Send it to us!
November 20, 2009
Happy Friday! Check out the new feature content we have available. Thanksgiving is right around the corner! Make sure you think about what you're most thankful for... Also, make sure you become a fan of Kombo on Facebook!!!

-- Ken Cauley, Editor in Chief

Kombo Breaker
FTW
Do you and your family celebrate Thanksgiving?
Vote!
(11/20/09 | 8:47 AM PST)
IBM Ending Cell Processor Development
(11/20/09 | 8:45 AM PST)
Infinity Ward Considered Alien Warfare?!
DiRT 2!!!
  • DiRT 2 for Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3
    Enter to win!
    E-mail us and include your full name, age and mailing address to enter.

  • Software
    Hardware
    All Time
    Weekly
    8.75m Japan
    26.08m America
    21.86m Others
    56.69M 
    1.19m Japan
    19.24m America
    12.94m Others
    33.37M 
    3.89m Japan
    10.32m America
    12.48m Others
    26.68M 
    28.36m Japan
    39.12m America
    46.54m Others
    114.01M 
    13.12m Japan
    17.80m America
    21.88m Others
    52.80M